Knowledge CentreTechnical Resources SearchConference PapersSeating Rules Increase Evacuation Risk in Light Rail Vehicles: Lessons Learned from Recent Canadian LRV Procurements

Seating Rules Increase Evacuation Risk in Light Rail Vehicles: Lessons Learned from Recent Canadian LRV Procurements

Abstract

As Canadian LRT systems expand and new fleets are specified for higher passenger loads, Light Rail Vehicle (LRV) interior layout becomes a safety-critical design choice rather than only a comfort or customer-experience issue. Recent Canadian sourcing and specification negotiations have highlighted a recurring conflict: comfort-driven seating rules, such as minimum transverse seating ratios, can unintentionally force arrangements that reduce effective aisle width, increase local merging friction and degrade emergency egress performance at the very loads the vehicle is required to carry. This paper evaluates three supplier-neutral LRV seating layouts: a baseline hybrid layout with transverse end seating pods, a longitudinal layout with sidewall seating and a continuous aisle, and a modified hybrid layout that retains some transverse seating while improving circulation. Two load cases are assessed: 145 passengers and an AW2 maximum of 195 passengers. The method combines an auditable bottleneck-capacity model with Monte Carlo simulation (N = 1000 trials per scenario) and reports mean and 95th percentile evacuation time. In the calibrated screening model, the baseline hybrid produces an AW2 mean near 310 s and a 95th percentile near 350 s, while the longitudinal layout produces about 114 s mean and 129 s at the 95th percentile. A modified hybrid is intermediate. The paper introduces an Egress Elasticity metric to compare load sensitivity and translates the findings into procurement-ready requirements for evacuation performance, aisle pinch points and waiver control. The numerical times are calibration-consistent screening outputs aligned with the accepted abstract; they are not measured evacuation-test results or a regulatory safety demonstration.

Keywords: Light Rail Vehicle; LRV procurement; emergency egress; passenger evacuation; seating layout; Monte Carlo simulation; bottleneck capacity; tail risk; performance-based specification; transit safety.

Conference Paper Details

Session title:
Decision Making, Evaluation and Monitoring
Author(s):
Faraji, Danial
Alif, Afridee Islam
Topics:
Transportation planning (MO)
Year:
2026